Andy Cohen Confirms He and Ex John Hill Have a Sex Tape From 2003

Yes, Andy Cohen and ex John Hill did make a sex tape when they were together — but don’t expect it to see the light of day.

Hill, 46, was the bartender during the Tuesday, January 7 episode of Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen. One segment during the show featured Hill listing the “Things Andy Should Do in 2025,” and they were pretty memorable.

Cohen, 56, noted that he was “already sweating” before Hill (who cohosts SiriusXM’s Radio Andy) even got started.

“Release our sex tape from 2003,” Hill said and Cohen started laughing. Guest and Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star Erika Jayne was quick to weigh in, saying, “Wait, I kind of want to see it.”

Real Housewives of New York City star Racquel Chevremont was also a WWHL guest and was screaming while sitting next to Jayne.

“Can we pull it up?” Chevremont, 53, asked. Jayne, 53, added, “Where is it?”

Cohen admitted, “I think there is one.” The Bravo boss appeared to come up with every excuse not to share it.

John Hill lists off the 5 hilarious things that @Andy should do in 2025 #WWHL pic.twitter.com/vZZmqpnkv7

— Watch What Happens Live! (@BravoWWHL) January 8, 2025

“The format. It’s on some janky format,” Cohen said. “No, I’m glad. We probably can’t even transfer it.”

Hill also suggested that Cohen “get t—” and “finally learn to read.” The radio host also asked Cohen for a raise. Finally, he joked that the WWHL host “needs to get rid of them kids” referring to Cohen’s son Ben, 5, and daughter Lucy, 2.

Things seem to be all in good fun between Cohen and Hill, who dated in the early 2000s — especially since they spend time together every day on air.

“I can’t think of too many exes that host something together — Sonny and Cher hosted after they got divorced — but I think it’s interesting for the listener to hear John absolutely shading me,” Cohen told Us Weekly exclusively last month. “Or he totally knocks me down in a way that no one else would go there. Even Jeff Lewis.”

During the same interview, Cohen told Us that he’s “proud of everybody” in the Radio Andy family for the achievements they created both on and off the show.

“They’ve all kind of come to this with their own personality and point of view,” he shared. “And they’ve all built their own followings and their own little universes on the channel.”